Appellate Court of Illinois October 31, 2007, 3-06-0930 Rel (Lohr v. Havens)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-10-2007

No. 3-06-0930

_________________________________________________________________

Filed October 31, 2007.

IN THE

APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS

THIRD DISTRICT

A.D., 2007

CHARLES R. LOHR, ) Appeal from the Circuit Court

) of the 13th Judicial Circuit,

Plaintiff-Appellee, ) La Salle County, Illinois,

)

v. )

)

TERRY HAVENS, Individually and )

as a shareholder, director and )

officer of Phoenix Paper ) No. 03-CH-688

Products, Inc.; SAMUEL J. )

MORRIS, Individually and as )

a shareholder, director and )

officer of Phoenix Paper )

Products, Inc.; and PHOENIX )

PAPER PRODUCTS, INC., an )

Illinois Corporation, ) Honorable

) Eugene P. Daugherty,

Defendants-Appellants. ) Judge, Presiding.

_________________________________________________________________

PRESIDING JUSTICE LYTTON delivered the opinion of the court:

_________________________________________________________________

Plaintiff Charles R. Lohr filed a complaint against defendants

Terry Havens, Samuel J. Morris and Phoenix Paper Products, Inc.,

seeking nonpublic shareholder relief, including the purchase of all

his shares, under the Business Corporations Act of 1983 (Act) (805

ILCS 5/12.56 (West 2002)). Havens filed an election to purchase

plaintiff’s shares under section 12.56(f) of the Act. The trial

court held that the election was defective and allowed plaintiff to

voluntarily dismiss his statutory claim. We affirm.

Lohr owns 44 shares of stock in Phoenix Paper, a privately-

held corporation. The majority shareholder, president and chairman

of the board is defendant, Terry Havens, who owns 56 shares. Two

other shareholders, James Durham and Tom Truckenbroad, hold five

shares each.

In October 2002, Durham sent a letter to Havens on behalf of

himself and Lohr, as directors and shareholders of Phonenix Paper,

requesting information regarding the handling of corporate assets.

Much correspondence followed in which Durham and Lohr questioned

the accounting methods and fiscal management of the company.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.