Ohio Court of Appeals July 26, 2007, No. 88933. (Brecksville v. Jones, 88933 (7-26-2007))

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-2007

JOURNAL ENTRY AND OPINION *Page 3 {¶ 1} This appeal is before the court on the accelerated docket pursuant to App.R. 11.1 and Loc. App.R. 11.1. {¶ 2} The plaintiff-appellant, City of Brecksville ("City"), appeals the trial court's granting the motion to suppress filed by defendant-appellee, Vernell Jones ("Jones"). For the following reasons, we affirm the decision of the trial court. {¶ 3} In 2006, Jones was charged with underage possession of alcohol. He filed a motion to suppress the evidence seized from a backpack in the trunk of his car. After a full hearing, the trial court granted his motion and dismissed the charge. {¶ 4} The following evidence was presented at the motion hearing. {¶ 5} On May 31, 2006, Brecksville police responded to a call from a resident, Adrian Gallucci ("Gallucci"), who complained that someone was knocking on her door, and she was concerned because she was not expecting anyone at 11 P.M.1 While en route to the call, Sergeant Mares observed a vehicle leaving the condominium complex where Gallucci lived. Sgt. Mares believed that the timing was "perfect" for the vehicle which he observed leaving the condominium complex to have just left Gallucci's condominium. Sgt. Mares saw what appeared to be three juvenile males in the car. He testified that, because this was the only vehicle leaving the condominium complex at 11 P.M., he suspected that the car's occupants may have been involved in the "incident." *Page 4 {¶ 6} Sgt. Mares stopped the vehicle to investigate. Jones was driving, and Gallucci's brother, Nicholas, and Mark Marek were passengers.2 Nicholas Gallucci told the officer that they had just left his sister's house after unsuccessfully trying to reach her. {¶ 7} As he spoke to the young men, Sgt. Mares detected a strong odor of cologne coming from inside the car. He suspected the cologne was an attempt to mask the smell of marijuana or alcohol. Another officer arrived on the scene and also detected the strong smell of cologne.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.