Superior Court of Rhode Island October 16, 2007, C.A. No. PC 06-2592 (Hicks v. Biltrite, Pc)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-10-2007

DECISION The Defendant, CertainTeed Corporation ("CertainTeed"), moves for summary judgment pursuant to Super. R. Civ. P. 56. The Plaintiffs, Deborah Hicks and William Hicks, object to the motion. Facts and Travel This is an asbestos-related product liability action which was commenced in May of 2006 against sixty-eight defendants. Deborah Hicks ("Plaintiff") and her husband, William Hicks ("Plaintiff spouse") allege that Plaintiff was exposed to various asbestos products and materials during her employment with Bell Telephone Company and in the process of renovating her deli. The instant application is brought by Defendant CertainTeed. Plaintiff contends that as a young teenager she was exposed to asbestos-containing roofing materials manufactured, supplied, or sold by CertainTeed when her brothers-in-law used these products in a small roof-repair project on a business attached to her family's home. Plaintiff alleges that she has developed mesothelioma and other asbestos-related pathologies as a result of this exposure. CertainTeed now moves for summary judgment, contending that Plaintiff cannot meet her prima facie burden of product identification and cannot prove a causal nexus between Defendant's asbestos-containing product and Plaintiff's injury. Specifically, CertainTeed *Page 2 challenges Plaintiff's identification of its product, as during her deposition Plaintiff initially identified the roofing product used by her brothers-in-law as "Bondex." Only after admitting mental fatigue and returning from a break did Plaintiff identify the product as "CertainTeen, or something like that." Depo. Trans. of DeborahHicks, Vol. II at 473-474. Furthermore, CertainTeed submits the affidavit of Charles B. Blakinger in support of its assertion that Plaintiff's description of the roofing materials used (rolled roofing, cements, and coatings) is inconsistent with CertainTeed roofing products at the time period in question (approximately 1957 — 1962).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.