Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York June 19, 2007 (D'Onofrio v. City of New York)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-2007

lead-opinion

Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Erin M. Peradotto, J.), entered December 5, 2005, which, inter alia, granted the motion of defendant City of New York to set aside the verdict as against it and for a directed verdict in its favor on the ground that it had not received prior written notice of the defect, affirmed, without costs.

The trial evidence showed that plaintiff fell on a defective subway grating in the vicinity of 20 Broad Street. However, the map filed with the Department of Transportation by the Big Apple Pothole and Sidewalk Protection Corporation, from which the City purportedly gained notice of the defect, only depicted uneven or raised areas of the sidewalk in the general area in front of 20 Broad Street, not a defective subway grating, and, as such, was inadequate to support an action premised on the defective subway grating (see Roldan v City of New York, 36 AD3d 484 [2007]; Waner v City of New York, 5 AD3d 288 [2004]). Concur—Gonzalez, Sweeny and Catterson, JJ.

dissent

Saxe, J.P.,

dissents in a memorandum as follows: I would reverse and deny the motion for a directed verdict, and reinstate the jury verdict as against defendant City. The jury’s finding that the City had received prior written notice of the defect was sufficiently supported and should not have been set aside.

Plaintiff testified that he fell on a defective area of the sidewalk in front of 20 Broad Street, where a subway grating *236was broken and unstable, and the crumbling cement next to the moving grating created a gap in which his feet got caught. The map filed with the Department of Transportation by the Big Apple Pothole and Sidewalk Protection Corporation contained two notations for that area, containing the map’s symbol for uneven or raised areas of the sidewalk.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.