Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 1, 2007 (Cunha v. Shapiro)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-05-2007

OPINION OF THE COURT

Dillon, J.

We address two issues of first impression for this Court involving “high-low” agreements. The first issue is whether a high-low agreement, when triggered, is a voluntary settlement of an action or, alternatively, a mere stipulated modification of the jury’s verdict. The second issue, if a high-low agreement constitutes a settlement, is whether the plaintiff must exchange a general release and stipulation of discontinuance to commence the defendant’s 21-day payment period before the plaintiff may file a judgment with interest, costs, and disbursements under CPLR 5003-a. For reasons discussed below, we find that a high-low agreement that is reached between parties and which is otherwise enforceable constitutes a settlement of the parties’ litigation. We also find that the high-low settlement must be treated like any other settlement for CPLR purposes, including application of the payment, judgment, and interest provisions of CPLR 5003-a, unless the provisions of the statute are expressly exempted from the stipulated terms of the high-low agreement.

I. Relevant Facts and Prior Proceedings

The plaintiff, Frank Cunha, commenced this action against the defendants, Blanche S. Shapiro, individually, and Blanche S. Shapiro, as executrix of the estate of Jesse Shapiro, seeking to *97recover damages for personal injuries allegedly sustained on April 23, 2003.1 By order dated July 14, 2004, the Supreme Court granted the plaintiffs motion for summary judgment on the issue of liability. On March 30, 2006, after the jury was selected for the trial on damages, and prior to the presentation of any evidence, the parties placed a high-low agreement on the record in open court. The parties agreed that regardless of the jury verdict, the plaintiff would receive damages of not less than $75,000 nor more than $325,000, and that the jury verdict would control for any amount rendered between $75,000 and $325,000.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.