Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York October 2, 2007 (State Division of Human Rights v. Berler)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-10-2007
OPINION OF THE COURT
Rivera, J.P
The primary issue presented on this appeal is whether the Supreme Court was authorized, pursuant to CPLR 2308 (b) (1), in effect, to preclude the State Division of Human Rights (here*34inafter the State Division) from considering certain documents as evidence in an administrative proceeding entitled Matter of Persuad v North Shore Internal Medicine Associates, P.C. For the reasons that follow, we find that CPLR 2308 (b) (1) does not encompass, as a penalty or sanction, the preclusion of evidence and does not permit the Supreme Court, in effect, to interfere with the State Division’s functions in considering certain documents as evidence.
I. Factual and Procedural Background
In 1996, Rookmatie Persuad filed a complaint with the State Division alleging that her former employer, North Shore Internal Medicine Associates, PC. (hereinafter North Shore), engaged in unlawful discriminatory practices in violation of the New York State Human Rights Law.
On November 23, 1999, North Shore served a nonjudicial subpoena duces tecum on Persuad. The subpoena sought, inter alia, copies of Persuad’s 1997-1999 state and federal income tax returns.
By order to show cause dated June 8, 2000, North Shore commenced a proceeding in the Supreme Court, Suffolk County, pursuant to CPLR 2308 (b), to compel Persuad’s compliance with the subject nonjudicial subpoena duces tecum. In a petition dated June 4, 2000, which accompanied the order to show cause, North Shore’s counsel requested that the Supreme Court hold Persuad in contempt and assess an “appropriate” penalty for her failure to “abide” by the subpoena duces tecum.
In an affirmation dated June 19, 2000, Persuad’s attorney argued that the subpoena duces tecum “sought extraordinary relief greatly in excess of that which may be sought in an attorney issued subpoena duces tecum and which document did not comply with Section 465.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit