Ohio Supreme Court March 28, 2007, No. 2005-2149 (City of Blue Ash v. Kavanagh)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-03-2007
lead-opinion
Lundberg Stratton, J.
I. Introduction
{¶ 1} Today this court must determine whether discretionary impoundment of a vehicle during a legitimate traffic stop constitutes an unreasonable seizure under the Fourth Amendment. For the reasons that follow, we find that the impoundment was justified and that the detention of the driver and subsequent search of the vehicle were lawful, and we therefore reverse the judgment of the court of appeals.
II. Facts
{¶ 2} On January 15, 2004, Blue Ash Police Officer Robert Rockel pulled over defendant-appellee, William Kavanagh, on Interstate 71 for driving with expired license plates. When asked for his driver’s license, defendant produced an expired driver’s license. Officer Rockel noticed that defendant appeared to be nervous, his voice trembled, and his hands were shaky.
{¶ 3} Because defendant’s operator’s license and tags had both been expired for almost three months and defendant could not lawfully drive the vehicle away, and the vehicle could not be parked or pushed to a safe location on the highway, Officer Rockel decided to impound defendant’s vehicle. Officer Rockel testified that with regard to a driver with an expired driver’s license and license plates, Blue Ash Police Department policy is to leave the decision whether to impound the vehicle to the officer’s discretion.
{¶ 4} After speaking to defendant, Officer Rockel went back to his cruiser, requested backup, and began writing a citation. Officer Rockel then returned to defendant and asked him to step out of his vehicle for the officer’s safety and because the vehicle was being impounded. Officer Rockel also asked defendant if there was any marijuana in the vehicle. In Officer Rockel’s opinion, the question *68seemed to make defendant more nervous, but defendant answered in the negative. Around that time, Officer Beth Monteith arrived as backup.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit