Court of Appeals of Oregon July 5, 2007, 00CV0394CC; A132322 (Jones v. Jones)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-07-2007

SCHUMAN, J.

In this action for partition, we have previously affirmed the trial court’s decision in favor of plaintiffs, Jones v. Jones, 194 Or App 496, 95 P3d 1135 (2004), rev den, 338 Or 301 (2005), and dismissed a subsequent appeal by defendant. Plaintiffs petition for attorney fees, arguing that there was no objectively reasonable basis for that second appeal. ORS 20.105. We allow the petition.

In 1985, the original owner of the property at issue in this case died and left the ranch in equal parts to her four children. Plaintiffs are two of the original owner’s four children; defendant is the original owner’s nephew, who acquired the interest of the other two children. A dispute arose between the co-owners culminating in 2001 with the trial court’s entry of a general judgment providing for partition by sale of the ranch, with the proceeds to be allocated among the parties. Defendant appealed, and we affirmed. Id.

Thereafter, the judicially ordered public sale of the ranch took place and, in due course, the court entered an order disbursing to the parties the proceeds of that sale. The court also entered a supplemental judgment awarding plaintiffs costs and attorney fees arising from defendant’s ongoing attempts to contest the validity of the judgment and the sale.

On May 19, 2006, defendant filed a notice of appeal purporting to appeal from “judgments entered in this case on 4-20-2006, by Judge Robert Millican.” The trial court register does not show entry of any judgment or order on that date. From documents attached to the notice of appeal, however, we were able to discern that defendant intended to appeal from the order to disburse sale proceeds and from the supplemental judgment awarding costs and attorney fees, actually entered not on April 20 but on April 21 and 24. Defendant’s notice of appeal was filed within 30 days of the dates of entry of those decisions; therefore, we determined that the appeal was timely. See Ensley v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.