Massachusetts Superior Court February 1, 2007, No.044245BLS2 (Vespers Realty Advisors, Inc. v. Binswanger Management Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-02-2007
Gants, Ralph D., J.
The defendants have moved for partial summary judgment as to Counts I and II of the *206complaint, alleging breach of contract and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The defendants argue that this Court’s Memorandum and Order dated May 1, 2006, effectively declaring unenforceable the provision of the contract providing for a partial arbitrator, rendered the entire contract unenforceable as a matter of law [21 Mass. L. Rptr. 77]. After hearing, the defendants’ motion for partial summary judgment is DENIED.
DISCUSSION
The gist of the defendants’ argument is that the dispute resolution provision that this Court found unenforceable may not be reasonably severed from the contract, so that the entire contract must be deemed void. There are two fundamental flaws — legal and equitable — in defendants’ argument.
The Marketing Agreement at issue provides, in the paragraph entitled, “Compensation”:
For all transactions between Vesper and BOM other than those specifically described in the following paragraphs, the Guidelines in Exhibit “A” will apply. The Guidelines are to be viewed solely as guidelines and each of the parties understands that there will need to be some flexibility in these Guidelines.
Marketing Agreement at ¶2(e)(1) p. 3.
Section III of Exhibit A, entitled “Referral Fees,” provides as follows:
3. Referral fees on leads to or from other Binswan-ger offices, divisions and affiliates shall be calculated from gross payments and based on the following guidelines:
a. 20%-35% for the party who refers the business
b. 50% for the party who services the business
c. 15%-20% for Binswanger of Massachusetts
d. Guidelines may be revised upon mutual agreement by the parties involved
e. In the event of a referral fee dispute, the facts surrounding the dispute shall be sent in writing to the Chief Financial Officer of BOM, who shall arbitrate.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit