Superior Court of The Virgin Islands February 5, 2007, Criminal No. 479/2006 (People v. Brathwaite)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-2007

KENDALL, Judge

MEMORANDUM OPINION

(February 5, 2007)

I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND

THIS MATTER came before the Court for Defendant’s Advice of Rights and Arraignment on January 4, 2007. The People were represented by Assistant Attorney General Brenda Scales while Assistant Territorial Public Defender Samuel Joseph represented the Defendant, *208who was present. Defendant was charged by Complaint with “Assault and Battery,” in violation of Title 14 V.I.C. §§ 291 and 299(2), and “Disturbance of the Peace,” in violation of Title 14 V.I.C. § 622(1). During the Hearing, Counsel for the People represented that the Attorney General had already determined that probable cause existed to arrest Defendant based upon the Complaint and Summons. Counsel contended that it was therefore unnecessary for this Court to engage in an independent probable cause finding before advising the Defendant of her rights.

Counsel for the People made the identical argument recently, in People of the Virgin Islands v. Raymond Monsanto, Criminal No. 444/2006. In that case, this Court advised Counsel that when an arrest is made based on a Complaint, the Court must make an independent finding of probable cause, and that the Attorney General’s determination of probable cause was improper. Over Counsel’s strenuous objection and because the People were unprepared to go forward with the Probable Cause Hearing, the matter was continued to the following day. The Court directed Counsel’s attention to SUPER. Ct. R. 123(b)(1) regarding its obligation to determine whether there was probable cause for the charges against the Defendant by reading the Rule to her in open court. Yet, just a few weeks later, Counsel for the People have returned to make the same argument before this Court. Counsel contended that it was not only unnecessary, but inappropriate for this Court to engage in an independent probable cause inquiry once the Attorney General has determined that probable cause existed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.