Norfolk County Circuit Court March 1, 2007, Case No. (Civil) CL06-634 (Slepin v. Colonial Chevrolet Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-2007

By Judge Everett A. Martin, Jr.

The plaintiff has filed a motion for judgment alleging breach of contract, fraud, and violation of the Virginia Consumer Protection Act, Code of Virginia § 59.1-196 et seq., all arising out of the repair of her car in 1999. The defendant has denied liability and filed several defensive motions. Mr. Coleman had no objection to the use of the plaintiffs deposition for the defendant’s plea of compromise and settlement, which was raised as an affirmative defense. Answer, paragraph 50.

The plaintiffs car was damaged in an accident in June of 1999. Her insurer had it towed to defendant’s shop for repair. The plaintiff testified in her deposition that she had no discussions with any employee of the defendant about the nature of the repairs or the manner in which they were to be performed. The repairs to her car were completed in July. With the exception of two minor items, one of which the defendant promptly corrected, she was satisfied with the work.

In September 2004, she noticed her rear bumper was loose. She took the car to the Norview Body Shop and was informed by Mr. Lassiter, the proprietor, that the 1999 repair had been performed by a “half-section” (also apparently sometimes called a “full section”). A “half-section” involves sawing the car in half and welding a different rear section onto the owner’s front section. The “half-sectioning” of the plaintiffs car had been performed improperly. It is not an issue for the pending motions, but the defendant claims the plaintiff authorized the “half-sectioning;” the plaintiff denies this.

*545The plaintiff, Mr. Lassiter, an “I-Car” representative, Mr. Lehew of the defendant, and perhaps another person met to discuss the condition of the plaintiffs car. At the meeting, Mr. Lehew agreed to supply Mr. Lassiter the necessary parts to repair the car, to pay Mr. Lassiter for the work, and to pay the plaintiff her “out-of-pocket” expenses, including her rental car expenses.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.