Idaho Court of Appeals November 1, 2007, 33475 (State v. Doe)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-2007

PERRY, Chief Judge.

John Doe, a minor, appeals from the intermediate appellate order of the district court affirming the magistrate’s decree that Doe fell within the purview of the Juvenile Corrections Act (JCA) for being incorrigible. For the reasons set forth below, we reverse the district court’s order and vacate the magistrate’s decree.

I.

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

Doe had been residing with his older sister in California for about a year when, on July 5, 2005, he went to his parents’ residence in Idaho. On July 7, Doe, who was fifteen years old, had a disagreement with his parents about whether he would be permitted to continue living with his sister in California. Doe wanted to return to California, but his parents wanted him to remain with them. During the disagreement, Doe left the residence to “cool off.” Doe’s sister, who was also present at the Idaho residence, became alarmed when Doe left and called the police. An officer located Doe across the street from his parents’ residence. Another officer went to the residence, where the parents told the officer that they did not want Doe to be charged with anything for his conduct. The officer with Doe warned him that, if the police were called back to the residence again that night, Doe would be arrested for being incorrigible. Later that night, the police responded to a call that there was a suicidal fifteen-year-old male at the same residence. Doe told the police that he had threatened to harm himself with a lamp cord. The officer who had spoken with Doe during the initial encounter then arrested Doe.

The state filed a petition alleging that Doe fell under the purview of the JCA. The petition alleged that Doe committed two counts of being incorrigible, in violation of Twin Falls City Ordinance 6-6-3, on or about July 7, 2005. The first count was for “arguing with his parents,” and the second count was for “leaving the house without permission.” The magistrate held an adjudicatory hearing.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.