Ho-Chunk Nation Trial Court June 14, 2007, No. CV 01-05 (Schmolke v. Ho-Chunk Nation)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-06-2007
JUDGMENT
MARK BUTTERFIELD, Chief Judge.
The Trial in this matter took place on June 19, 2001 at the Ho-Chunk Nation Court House in Black River Falls, WI before the Hon. Mark Butterfield, Chief Trial Judge. The plaintiff was represented by Mark Goodman, Esq. of Goodman and Osborne Sparta, WI and the defendants were represented by John Swimmer, Esq. of the Ho-Chunk Nation Dept, of Justice.
INTRODUCTION
This is an employment dispute between an employee who accepted a position with the Ho-Chunk Casino in a management position as “Interim Marketing Director” and the Ho-Chunk Nation Executive Director of Business. Fundamentally this is a case about a misunderstanding as to what type of position the plaintiff, Mr. Schmolke, held. This is critical under Ho-Chunk Nation law because should Mr. Schmolke be classified as a permanent employee he has a right to grieve and to certain job protections including the right to be dismissed only for just cause. However, if Mr. Schmolke was more properly classified as an “LTE” or Limited Term Employee he has no right to grieve and may be dismissed for any reason. That is the crux of this case. What was the proper legal classification of Mr. Schmolke at the time of his dismissal? The plaintiff contends that he was hired under an expectation that his position would ripen into full time permanent employment and the defendant contends that Mr. Schmolke was properly classified as an LTE and had no expectation or right to further employment.
Both positions are not perfectly supported or there would be no dispute. Mr. Schmolke worked 92 days in the last position he held as Interim Marketing Director at Ho-Chunk Casino, which is two days longer than necessary to survive a probationary period of 90 days. It is undisputed that Mr. Schmolke was credited with annual and sick leave, both types of leave LTE’s are not eligible for. However, the defendant points out that there is no special classification as “Interim” anything and so the closest Mr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit