Court of Appeals of Wisconsin January 31, 2008, 2006AP2502-CR (State v. Nawrocki)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-01-2008
HIGGINBOTHAM, EJ.
¶ 1. Jonathan Nawrocki appeals a judgment of conviction for robbery with use of force as a party to a crime, contending that the circuit court should have suppressed arrest scene showup
1
identifications of him by the victim and a third-party witness under
State v. Dubose,
2005 WI 126, 285 Wis. 2d 143, 699 N.W.2d 582.
2
¶ 2. The issue presented in this case is whether a showup identification is necessary, thus meeting the first test of admissibility under
Dubose,
when probable cause exists to justify an arrest of a suspect, but it does not exist on the particular offense under investigation.
3
We conclude that whenever probable cause exists to
*232
justify detention of a suspect, regardless of whether it exists on the offense under investigation, a showup identification is not necessary within the meaning of
Dubose.
¶ 3. Because it is undisputed that officers, while lacking probable cause to arrest Nawrocki on the offense under investigation, had probable cause to arrest him on another offense, we conclude the showup was not necessary and was thus inadmissible under
Dubose.
We therefore reverse the circuit court's order denying Nawrocki's motion to suppress evidence of the showup identifications. However, we remand for the circuit court to determine whether the victim's in-court identification was based on an untainted, independent source, and for further proceedings that may be necessary consistent with this opinion.
Background
¶ 4. Following a jury trial, Jonathan Nawrocki was convicted of one count of robbery with use of force as a party to a crime, contrary to Wis. Stat. §§ 943.32(l)(a) and 939.05 (2005-06).
4
The conviction stemmed from the June 28, 2005 robbery and assault of Mark Gerhardt, which occurred shortly before 2 a.m. while Gerhardt was parked outside of his mother's residence at 1515 South 72nd Street in West Allis.
*233
¶ 5. At trial, Gerhardt testified that he was listening to music in his van when two men approached.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit