Indiana Court of Appeals August 25, 2008, 81A05-0712-CV-741 (Pflum v. Wayne County Board of Commissioners)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-08-2008
OPINION
BAKER, Chief Judge.
Appellant-plaintiff Lowell J. Pflum appeals the judgment in favor of appellee-defendant Wayne County Board of Commissioners (the Board), claiming that the evidence was insufficient to support the conclusion that the Board’s improvement project had not resulted in the discharge or casting of surface water upon Pflum’s lot in accordance with the common enemy doctrine. Finding that the trial court properly applied the common enemy doctrine in determining that Wayne County (the County) did not collect surface water and cast it on Pflum’s property, we affirm the judgment of the trial court.
FACTS
In 1992, Kay and Lowell Pflum (collectively, the Pflums) entered into an informal land contract with James Jones for the purchase of a residence and additional acreage in Wayne County. At that time, the Pflums began farming a portion of the ground, but they did not move into the residence until sometime in 1995.
The residence is approximately 400 feet from Sorber Road, a county highway that runs east and west. The Pflums’ yard and the surrounding areas are the natural destination for rainwater from a watershed that is located approximately 580 acres to the north. The drainage from the watershed flows to the point of the Pflums’ front yard, across their driveway, around the house, and continues to the south. Prior to the commencement of the project, water coming down from the watershed traveled under an old, deteriorating, and narrow culvert and passed under Sorber Road, and there was a curving, meandering ditch that traveled through the Pflums’ yard. During moderate rainfall, the culvert would channel the water directly into the Pflums’ yard. However, during heavy rainfall, the water would overflow and cover an area about 450 feet wide. As a result, the surrounding areas — including the Pflums’ yard — would flood. Even when water did not spill over the road, it collected in the middle of the Pflums’ yard.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit