District Court, N.D. Ohio June 10, 2008, 3:06CR719 (United States v. Mazloum)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-06-2008
ORDER
JAMES G. CARR, Chief Judge.
This is a criminal prosecution in which the government has charged the defendant, Wassim Mazloum, with conspiring with two other defendants to: 1) kill, maim, or injure United States servicemen in Iraq; and 2) provide material support to terrorists in Iraq. Among other contentions, the government argues that the defendants desired to participate in
jihad
by joining in the Iraqi insurgency.
The defendant’s attorneys stated that they would be calling two witnesses who would testify that, about six weeks after the only meeting, on February 16, 2005, of all three defendants, Mazloum made statements pertinent on the issue of intent. According to his attorneys, Mazloum stated to the two witnesses whom they wanted to call that
jihad
in Iraq was not permissible under Islamic law because Iraq was not an Islamic nation and no appropriate authority had issued a
fatwah
authorizing
jihad
in Iraq.
On the basis of that representation and over the government’s objection — but without extensive argument from counsel or
voir dire
of the witnesses — I initially interpreted Rule 803(3) of the Federal Rules of Evidence in favor of admitting this testimony (Doc. 788). I based that decision principally on
U.S. v. Bertram,
477 F.2d 1329, 1330 (10th Cir.1973) (holding that defendant’s testimony as to his religious beliefs, though not providing a defense to criminal conduct done knowingly, is admissible “evidence as to state of mind establishing that there was no criminal intent”) and
Morejon v. State,
394 So.2d 1100, 1101 (Fla.App.1981) (stating that “[t]here was no error in admitting testimony concerning the defendant’s ‘religious’ beliefs ...; testimony of a witness to the effect that the defendant had stated that men should settle their differences ‘in blood’ was relevant as probative of the defendant’s motive, intent or state of mind.”).
The government promptly asked that I reconsider my ruling.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit