Court of Appeals of Utah January 25, 2008, 20060757-CA (State v. Worthen)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-01-2008
AMENDED OPINION
1
GREENWOOD, Presiding Judge:
¶ 1 The State brings this interlocutory appeal from the trial court’s order granting Defendant’s motion for in camera inspection of the alleged victim’s (B.W.) mental health records. The State asserts that the trial court erred by granting Defendant’s motion because (1) the trial court failed to determine whether Defendant’s request fell within an exception to the physician-patient privilege under rule 506(b) of the Utah Rules of Evidence,
see
Utah R. Evid. 506(b), (d); (2) the sought-after records do not relate to an element or claim of Defendant’s defense, as required by rule 506(d)(1) of the Utah Rules of Evidence,
see id.
R. 506(d)(1); and (3) Defendant did not establish, with reasonable certainty, that the records contain exculpatory, material evidence. The State also contends, and Defendant agrees, that it was
*666
error for the trial court to order that his law clerk would review the mental health records.
¶ 2 We agree that the trial judge should personally review the records, but otherwise affirm the trial court’s order.
BACKGROUND
¶ 3 On or about July 8, 2005, Defendant and his wife’s adopted child, B.W., attempted suicide and was subsequently admitted to the University of Utah Neuropsychiatric Institute (UNI). During a mental health evaluation, B.W. explained that she had “a lot of family strife recently ... [and was] getting in frequent fights with her mother.” She also reported prior abuse by her biological grandparents, but denied any other abuse. Defendant states that prior to the suicide attempt, B.W. had a heated argument with her mother.
¶ 4 During her nineteen-day stay at UNI, B.W. participated in individual, group, and family therapy. Afterward, B.W. participated in outpatient counseling on at least twelve occasions. During that time period, B.W. wrote about her family in a journal, and some of the entries describe B.W.’s angry feelings toward her mother. For example, in one entry B.W.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit