Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas May 7, 2008, PD-0936-07 (State v. Garcia-Cantu, Candelario)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-05-2008

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

OF TEXAS

NO. PD-0936-07, PD-0937-07

STATE OF TEXAS

v.

CANDELARIO GARCIA-CANTU, Appellee

ON APPELLEE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW

FROM THE NINTH COURT OF APPEALS

MONTGOMERY COUNTY

K ELLER, P.J., filed a dissenting opinion in which K EASLER and

H ERVEY, JJ., joined.

To understand this case, we must first understand the nature of the trial court’s ruling.

Appellee’s complaint at trial was that Officer Okland’s approach of the vehicle constituted a “stop”

without reasonable suspicion in violation of the Fourth Amendment:

At this point, Your Honor – well, we’re objecting to the stop, and the approaching

vehicle, at least the objection made in this case. That’s all we need to argue about

here today, if they had a valid reason for stopping and making their investigation and

search that they conducted. Anything that happened afterwards is sort of irrelevant

to our argument here.

When the State sought to introduce the video of the encounter, appellee reiterated the nature of his

GARCIA-CANTU DISSENT – 2

complaint as relating only to the very beginning: “No objection, just that all we need is the first

frame, or – yeah, the first frame to show where the vehicle was parked, and I have no objection to

that.” In sustaining a later objection at the hearing, the trial court confirmed that the suppression

issue was limited to the initial contact between Officer Okland and appellee:

[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Objection, your honor, to any testimony that followed the

stop. What we’re questioning is the stop, and not anything that happened afterwards.

[THE COURT]: Yeah, that will be sustained.

The Court recites ten circumstances that it believes support the trial court’s ruling, but only

one of those circumstances comes close to supporting a finding that the initial contact between

Officer Okland and appellee constituted the onset of a detention for Fourth Amendment purposes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.