Louisiana Court of Appeal June 19, 2009, 2008 CA 0952 (Courvelle v. Louisiana Recreational & Used Motor Vehicle Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-2009

McClendon, j.

| ^Plaintiffs, Phillip Courvelle and the Louisiana Recreational Vehicle Association, Inc. (association),

1

filed suit to enforce the open meetings law and for an injunction. After the trial court rendered a judgment in plaintiffs’ favor, the named defendants, the Louisiana Recreational and Used Motor Vehicle Commission, and certain commission members, Janai Shar-key, Scott Graham, Richard Prestridge, Paul Rossi, Aaron Gables, and Julia Frederick, appealed. Three other commissioners, Mike Roberts, Byron Wright, and Johnny Brakefield, filed a separate appeal.

2

We affirm in part and reverse in part.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A public meeting of the commission was noticed for February 19, 2008. Posted with the date was the agenda and a notice of intent to enter into an executive session during the public, open meeting. The stated purpose of the executive session was to consider ongoing litigation, listed by name and docket number, between the commission and Bourget’s of the South, L.L.C. (Bourget’s),

3

related prospective litigation, and attorney billings.

*343

At the February meeting, the commission, by a roll call, determined that thirteen members were present, two did not answer, and thirteen qualified as a quorum. Plaintiff, Mr. Courvelle, answered the roll call as a commissioner. The attorney representing the association was also recorded as being present.

At the beginning of the public meeting, the commission held a voice vote to approve a motion to go into executive session to discuss the “legal matters.” However, after the motion carried, but before actually entering the executive session and without an interruption in the recording of the meeting, the | .^commission considered whether public comments should be heard first. After some discussion, one of the attorneys for the commission, Mr. Robert Hallack, advised the commission, as follows: “If you violate the open meetings law, you are subject to criminal penalties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.