District Court, D. Rhode Island September 2, 2009, C.A. 08-05 S (D & H Therapy Associates, LLC v. Boston Mutual Life Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-09-2009
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
WILLIAM E. SMITH, District Judge.
This matter is before the Court on the parties’ cross motions. Defendant moves for summary judgment on Plaintiffs’ Amended Complaint, and moves to strike certain affidavits and exhibits submitted by Plaintiffs on the grounds that these documents are not part of the administrative record. In addition, Defendant has filed a counterclaim for $145,958.32, representing benefits it alleges were overpaid to Plaintiff Robin Dolan. Plaintiffs object to Defendant’s motions for summary judgment and to strike their submissions, and cross move for summary judgment on Defendant’s counterclaim, and as to liability on three counts of their five-count complaint.
In her Complaint, Plaintiff Robin Dolan (“Dolan”) alleges that her long-term disability insurance benefits were wrongly terminated by Defendant Boston Mutual Life Insurance Company (“Boston Mutual”). Dolan is a 50% partner in several physical therapy clinics operating as D
&
H Therapy Associates, LLC (“D & H”), which sponsored and administered the long-term disability plan, and which joins Dolan in her suit against Boston Mutual. Dolan twice appealed the termination of benefits to Boston Mutual’s third-party claims administrator, Disability Reinsurance Management Services (“DRMS”). Unsuccessful in those efforts, she now appeals the termination to this Court.
Background
Robin Dolan is a physical therapist, who with a partner, Kim Havunen, created several related business enterprises, of which they were each 50% owners. Associated Professional Management, Inc., (“APM”) is an S corporation,
1
and D & H Therapy Associates was originally a partnership. In 2004, the D & H partnership was converted to the Plaintiff entity, a limited liability company.
2
D & H provides physical, occupational, and speech therapy at several clinics located throughout Rhode Island. When Dolan was actively employed by D & H, she served as director of clinical services and as a physical therapist.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit