Texas Supreme Court August 28, 2009, 07-0043 (Dynegy Midstream Services, Ltd. Partnership v. Apache Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-08-2009

combined-opinion

Justice WILLETT

delivered the opinion of the Court.

In this gas-contract dispute, Apache Corporation seeks recovery for an allegedly large volume of “unaccounted-for” gas that disappeared between production at Apache’s wellheads (where title to all gas transferred to the processor) and sale to customers at the processing facility (the tailgate). We hold that Apache’s claim is contrary to the governing contract language, which focuses on gas sold, not gas delivered, thus avoiding disputes over how (and how much) gas failed to reach the point of sale. When calculating the proceeds due to Apache under these “percentage of proceeds” contracts, only one criterion matters: sales. Common throughout the natural-gas industry, these contracts unambiguously base payment on the amount of gas ultimately sold at the tailgate (not the amount initially delivered at the wellhead), and Apache admits it was paid in full for “every molecule of gas” sold at the tailgate of the processing plants.

Our decision today, besides clarifying the contractual payment standard — one

*166

that rewards processors for minimizing leakage and maximizing the amount of gas actually sold — also addresses other claims. In sum, we affirm the court of appeals’ judgment in part and reverse it in part, and remand to the trial court to render a judgment in conformity with this opinion.

I. Background

Though technical in nature, and part of a voluminous record, the relevant facts are neither complicated nor disputed. Apache owns gas wells in Texas and New Mexico. Apache and Versado Gas Processors, LLC are parties to eighteen gas-purchase contracts in issue. Under these contracts, gas is transported from Apache’s wellheads through Versado’s gathering system (pipelines and compressor stations) to Versado’s three processing plants:

1

the Eunice, Monument, and Saunders plants. While en route some hydrocarbon liquids, known as field condensate, precipitate out of the gas and are removed by Versado.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.