New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division May 11, 2009, A-0964-08T3 (NJ CURE v. Estate of Hamilton)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-05-2009
970 A.2d 1051 (2009) 407 N.J. Super. 247 NJ CURE, Plaintiff-Respondent, v. The ESTATE OF Robert HAMILTON, Defendant, and Albert DeNeve, M.D., Defendant-Appellant. No. A-0964-08T3 Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. Argued March 25, 2009. Decided May 11, 2009. Glenn W. Banks, Mahwah, argued the cause for appellant (Tuttle & Zisgen, attorneys; Mr. Banks, of counsel and on the briefs). Paul I. Konopka, argued the cause for respondent (Melli, Guerin & Wall, P.C., attorneys; Kenneth L. O'Donnel, Jr., Paramus, of counsel; Cheryl A. Binosa, on the brief). Before Judges PAYNE,[1] WAUGH and NEWMAN. The opinion of the court was delivered by WAUGH, J.A.D. Appellant Albert DeNeve, M.D., appeals from an order sanctioning him for repeated failure to produce copies of the *1052 medical records of his patient, Robert Hamilton, in connection with a Personal Injury Protection (PIP) arbitration. Although we are of the opinion that DeNeve should have acted much earlier in supplying the records and opposing the enforcement motions brought by plaintiff NJ Cure, it is clear that the trial court never had personal jurisdiction over DeNeve in this matter. Consequently, we must reverse and vacate the order. I We glean the following facts from the record. In a PIP arbitration proceeding between NJ Cure and the now deceased Robert Hamilton, NJ Cure sent a letter dated March 14, 2007, to DeNeve, enclosing a subpoena duces tecum and deposition notice, seeking production of his medical records with respect to Hamilton. We note that DeNeve was apparently not the medical provider whose bills were the subject of the PIP arbitration. On April 25, 2007, NJ Cure mailed another letter to DeNeve, again enclosing a subpoena and deposition notice. Both of those letters, although mailed to DeNeve, purported to "serve" him with the subpoenas. However, DeNeve was never personally served with the subpoenas as required by Rule 1:9-3. See also R. 4:14-7(a).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit