Court of Appeals of Wisconsin November 25, 2009, 2009AP507 (Vohs v. Donovan)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-11-2009

VERGERONT, J.

¶ 1. This dispute arises out of a residential offer to purchase that contained the phrase "offer is subject to sellers obtaining home of their choice on or before February 20, 2007," a date two days after both the buyers and the sellers signed the offer. The circuit court granted the buyers' motion for summary judgment on the ground that this phrase made the contract indefinite and illusory and therefore the buyers were not obligated to purchase the sellers' home. The sellers appeal.

¶ 2. We conclude there are material factual disputes that prevent summary judgment on both the ground of indefiniteness and the ground of illusoriness. With respect to indefiniteness, when the contingency language is considered along with the extrinsic evidence submitted by the sellers, there is a reasonable inference that both parties understood that the contingency referred to a particular pending transaction, and that understanding makes the contingency sufficiently definite. With respect to illusoriness, there is a reasonable inference that fulfilling the contingency was not wholly within the sellers' control, and therefore the contingency did not make the sellers' promise illusory. Accordingly, we reverse and remand for further proceedings.

*725

BACKGROUND

¶ 3. On February 18, 2007, Paul and Teresa Donovan signed an offer to purchase the home of Terry and Vicki Vohs for the sum of $550,000. The offer included a contingency providing that the "offer is subject to sellers obtaining home of their choice on or before Feb. 20, 2007." The Vohses accepted the offer to purchase on the same date.

¶ 4. According to the Vohses' unrebutted submissions, as of February 18, 2007, they had a pending counteroffer to purchase another home. That counteroffer contained a provision that it had to be accepted on or before February 19, 2007. On February 19, the counteroffer was accepted and the Vohses' broker communicated this to the Donovans.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.