Court of Appeals of Maryland April 8, 2009, 99, 98, September Term, 2008 (Jackson v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-04-2009
HARRELL, J.
With the filing of this opinion, this Court will have completed a “Goldilocks” trilogy.
1
In
Department of Human Resources v. Howard,
397 Md. 353, 918 A.2d 441 (2007), in the context of an in banc proceeding in the Court of Special Appeals, we found that more than 13 judges was too much. In
Wildwood Medical Center, L.L.C. v. Montgomery County,
405 Md. 489, 954 A.2d 457 (2008) (per curiam), in the context of a three-judge panel of that court, where the nominal author of the opinion in the case passed-away before a final opinion could be filed and the remaining judges split over the result, we found the number of judges too few. In the present case, we shall find that two judges in agreement are just right.
The common issue involved in this consolidated appeal of two cases is whether a judgment by the Court of Special Appeals is valid where one of the three judges on the panel that heard argument died before the case was decided, but the remaining two judges, agreeing on the reasoning and result, filed an opinion nonetheless. Following its purported decision in one of the cases involved here, the Court of Special Appeals denied the appellant’s Motion to Recall Mandate, holding that a two-judge majority of a panel lawfully may decide an appeal despite the intervening death of the third judge on the panel.
Jackson v. State,
182 Md.App. 588, 597, 959 A.2d 84, 89 (2008). In doing so, the Court of Special Appeals distinguished this Court’s opinion in
Wildwood, supra,
on the basis that
Wild-wood
applies “only to cases in which one member of the panel [of the Court of Special Appeals] has passed away and the two remaining panel members disagree as to the decision.”
Jackson,
182 Md.App. at 590, 959 A.2d at 85. For the reasons that
*234
follow, we affirm the judgments of the intermediate appellate court.
Relevant Factual and Procedural Background
Jackson v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit