Court of Appeals of Oregon April 1, 2009, 030331245; A122955 (State v. Jackson)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-04-2009

*35

BREWER, C. J.

This case is before us on remand from the Supreme Court, which vacated our prior decision,

State v. Jackson,

201 Or App 208, 117 P3d 315

(Jackson I),

in light of

State v. Ramirez,

343 Or 505, 173 P3d 817 (2007),

adh’d to as modified on recons,

344 Or 195, 179 P3d 673 (2008), and

State v. Fults,

343 Or 515, 173 P3d 822 (2007).

State v. Jackson,

345 Or 315, 195 P3d 63 (2008). In

Jackson I,

we vacated defendant’s sentences and remanded for resentencing because the trial court had imposed a departure sentence based on judicial findings. That factfinding constituted plain error, and we exercised our discretion to correct it. The issue before us on remand is whether, in light of

Ramirez

and

Fults,

we properly exercised our discretion under

Ailes v. Portland Meadows, Inc.,

312 Or 376, 381-82, 823 P2d 956 (1991). We conclude that our exercise of discretion in

Jackson I

was erroneous. Accordingly, we affirm.

Defendant was convicted of one count of second-degree robbery and one count of third-degree robbery. On the second-degree robbery conviction, the trial court imposed a durational departure sentence of 102 months’ imprisonment. The court imposed that sentence because “defendant [was] on supervision at time of incident and persistent involvement.”

In this case, the trial court did not explicitly state that it was relying on the departure factors it found either singly or in combination, and therefore we assume that the court did not consider each factor to be independently sufficient to support a departure.

State v. Wilson,

111 Or App 147, 826 P2d 1010 (1992). Thus, remand for resentencing may be warranted if either one of the factors relied on by the trial court is subject to legitimate debate.

See Ramirez,

343 Or at 513 (setting out “legitimate debate” standard for exercise of discretion to review unpreserved challenges to departure sentences based on judicial findings of fact).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.