Nevada Supreme Court August 6, 2009, 51321 (Zamora v. Price)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-2009

OPINION

By the Court,

Cherry, J.:

In this appeal, we consider the constitutionality of NRS 38.259(2), which requires that, when a party requests a new trial at the conclusion of mandatory nonbinding arbitration proceedings in a short trial matter, the arbitrator’s findings must be admitted during the new trial. Specifically, we address whether the admission of this arbitration award deprives a party of the constitutional right to a jury trial and whether it violates equal protection rights. For the reasons set forth below, we conclude that NRS 38.259(2)’s requirement that the arbitration award be admitted at the new trial does not violate a party’s constitutional right to a jury trial or a party’s right to equal protection under the law.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY

The procedural history of this case is straightforward. Respondent Tyshae Price filed a complaint in district court against appellant Steve Zamora, asserting tort claims arising out of an automobile accident. Because the amount at issue in the suit was less than $40,000, the case was referred to Nevada’s nonbinding arbitration program as mandated by NRS 38.250(1).

1

After a hearing, the arbitrator awarded Price $18,000. Zamora then requested a new trial, which was conducted as part of the short trial program. The short trial jury also awarded Price $18,000, and judgment was subsequently entered on that verdict by the judge pro tempore.

2

Zamora now appeals.

*391

DISCUSSION

Under NRS 38.250(l)(a), civil actions for damages filed in district court that do not exceed $50,000, as the amount in controversy, must, subject to certain exceptions, first be submitted to nonbinding arbitration. This requirement is mandatory for district courts in any judicial district with populations of 100,000 or more and permissive for Nevada’s remaining judicial districts. NRS 38.255(2). Within 30 days after an arbitration award is served on the parties, any party may request a new trial in district court. NAR 18(A).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.