Kentucky Supreme Court May 21, 2009, 2007 SC 000282 (Moore Pontiac, Buick, Gmc, Inc. v. Candria Scott)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-2009

,*uprrmr (~vurf of

2006-SC-000693-DG

TIMOTHY MORGAN

ON REVIEW FROM COURT OF APPEALS

V. CASE NOS . 2004-CA-002350-MR AND 2004-CA-002363-MR

PIKE CIRCUIT COURT NO. 03-CI-01352

CANDRIA SCOTT

AND JAMES E . SCOTT, JR . APPELLEES

AND 2006-SC-000701-DG

CANDRIA SCOTT

AND JAMES E . SCOTT, JR . APPELLANTS

ON REVIEW FROM COURT OF APPEALS

V. CASE NOS . 2004-CA-002350-MR AND 2004-CA-002363-MR

PIKE CIRCUIT COURT NO . 03-CI-01352

MOORE PONTIAC, BUICK, GMC, INC . APPELLEE

AND 2007-SC-000282-DG

MOORE PONTIAC, BUICK, GMC, INC. CROSS-APPELLANT

ON REVIEW FROM COURT OF APPEALS

V. CASE NOS . 2004-CA-002350-MR AND 2004-CA-002363-MR

PIKE CIRCUIT COURT NO . 03-CI-01352

CANDRIA SCOTT CROSS-APPELLEES

AND JAMES E. SCOTT, JR.

OPINION OF THE COURT

AFFIRMIMG

INTRODUCTION

Among other issues, these appeals ask us to examine the extent of a car

dealer's liability for injuries arising out of accidents that occur during a test

drive. We hold that, at least under the facts presented, the dealer should not

have been held liable .

We also consider the question of whether a tortfeasor to whom the jury

apportioned only a portion of the liability for the plaintiffs' injuries becomes

liable for all of the plaintiff's damages when, on appeal, it is determined that

the remaining co-defendant, against whom fault was also apportioned, was not

a proximate cause of the injury and should not have been found liable. We

conclude that he does.

II . FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY.

The legal questions presented in these appeals are complex, but the

essential underlying facts of the appeals are common and simple. Timothy

Morgan stopped at Moore Pontiac, Buick, GMC, Inc ., to test drive a Chevrolet

Silverado pickup truck.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.