Ohio Court of Appeals March 20, 2009, No. L-07-1125. (State v. Nuhfer, L-07-1125 (3-20-2009))

Also known as

United States · · · 20-03-2009

DECISION AND JUDGMENT {¶ 1} Appellant appeals his murder conviction rendered following a trial to the bench in the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas. For the reasons that follow, we affirm. *Page 2 {¶ 2} On the morning of July 12, 2004, an employee of an East Toledo florist found the nude body of a woman, face down in a pile of sawdust behind his shop. Police later identified the decedent as Melissa Gregg, a prostitute who worked in the neighborhood. {¶ 3} Police noted three stab wounds on the victim's body. Blood flow from these wounds suggested that she was killed in the position in which she was found. The coroner placed the time of death as no more than 24 hours before the body was found and, likely, eight to 12 hours prior. {¶ 4} An autopsy revealed that in addition to being stabbed, Gregg had been strangled. Indeed, the coroner later testified that although one of the stab wounds penetrated the heart, the resulting small amount of blood suggested that the heart had stopped or nearly stopped when the wound was inflicted. Semen was found in the victim's anal cavity. The state crime lab extracted DNA from the sample, but initially found no match in its database. {¶ 5} Police obtained surveillance video from a security camera in a convenience store across the street from where the body was found. Through the tape they found witnesses who placed Gregg outside the convenience store, arguing with an individual named Louis Boyd, on the night she was killed. {¶ 6} Police interviewed Boyd and executed a search warrant on his apartment. During the search, police detectives found a T-shirt with traces of sawdust consistent with that found under the body. Nevertheless, police were unable to otherwise connect Boyd to the killing. Boyd would die of cancer a year later. *Page 3 {¶ 7} In 2006, appellant, William E. Nuhfer, II, was convicted of an unrelated felony which resulted in a routine collection of a DNA sample.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.