District Court of Appeal of Florida March 11, 2009, No. 4D07-1065 (Cowan v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-03-2009
lead-opinion
FARMER, J.
Defendant and a companion were arrested for burglary, handcuffed and left unattended in the rear seat of a police car. No one else was present, but a video monitor recorded them.
At trial the prosecution sought to admit excerpts of the recording. The state attorney contended that the companion could be understood as saying to defendant: “Damn, you think they caught us for the home invasion, home burglary?” and “Hey, we did not leave anything in there?” The prosecution argued that defendant’s lips seemed to be moving, that he appeared to say: “They’ve got it. They’ve got it.”1
Defendant objected, saying that he did not respond in any way to his companion. He argued that, because he had been just arrested and taken into custody, the admission of the tape showing his silence to any declarations by his companion would violate his right against self-incrimination. The court allowed the evidence, reasoning that defendant was not being interrogated by police at the time.
Later, defendant testified on his own behalf, denying involvement in the burglary. He testified that he did not say anything while seated in the police car. When asked on cross-examination why his mouth seemed to be moving as in speech, he denied that his lips were moving. He denied ever saying: “they’ve got it; they’ve got it.” He explained that he remained silent in the police vehicle in spite of his companion’s declarations because he was angry at being arrested. Then this inquiry by the prosecutor:
Q. Did you at any point say to him: ‘What are you talking about, what burglary?’
A. No, because I was mad that he got me arrested.
[[Image here]]
Q. How come you didn’t say: ‘What burglary are you talking about?’ How come you didn’t say that?
A. I don’t know what you’re talking about.
Q. How come you didn’t say — when he said ‘damn, you think they caught us?’ — why didn’t you say ‘I’m not part of it. What are you talking about? I was not with you.’
A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit