Louisiana Court of Appeal March 11, 2009, No. CA 2008-452 (Cimarex Energy Co. v. Mauboules)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-03-2009

SAUNDERS, Judge.

11 FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY:

This appeal arises from an Amended Final Judgment by the Fifteenth Judicial District Court, in which the trial court found that Appellants1 (hereinafter collectively referred to as “Cimarex”) brought a concursus proceeding, under La.Code Civ.P. art. 4658, without having a legitimate basis to do so, thereby unreasonably withholding royalty payments from Appel-lees2 (hereinafter collectively referred to as “Orange River”). A review of the facts leading up to this appeal is instructive.

In 1997, Katherine Daigle Mauboules and other members of her family sold royalty interests in their land to Ereunao Oil & Gas, Inc. (hereinafter “Ereunao”). This royalty deed contained an “Off Tract Production Clause” that would later become the source of Mauboules’ assertion that she might be entitled to the royalty interests she had sold to Ereunao. Years after Ereunao’s purchase of royalty interest from Mauboules, Orange River made three different purchases of royalty interests from Ereunao’s assignees, Lawrence and Lorena Brock, in April 2004, August 2004, and February 2005.

Meanwhile, during February of 2003, Ci-marex acquired a mineral lease from Ma-boules and drilled a well, which began production in January 2004. The Cimarex *403lease agreement had been reached after a year of unsuccessful negotiations with Mauboules and only after the addition of three key provisions: |⅞(1) Cimarex would pay Kenneth Privat (hereinafter “Privat”), Maboules’ attorney, $7,500.00 in legal fees to offset future legal expenses incurred by filing suit against a royalty purchaser known as Ereunao Oil & Gas, Inc. et al.; (2) Cimarex would place the royalties in suspense until the suit against Ereunao was over; and (3) Cimarex would pay Ma-boules $75,000.00 if (a) her lawsuit against Ereunao was unsuccessful and (b) a successful well was drilled and the well reached 150% payout.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.