New York Supreme Court January 6, 2009 (Sellers v. LaPietra)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-01-2009
OPINION OF THE COURT
John C. Egan, Jr., J.
Plaintiffs/petitioners, Michael Sellers and Alexander MacKay (petitioners), commenced this proceeding by order to show cause, seeking a preliminary injunction (1) enjoining the defendants/respondents Schoharie County Board of Elections, Lewis L. Wilson and Clifford C. Hay (hereinafter the county respondents) from certifying the results of the November 4, 2008 election in the Village of Cobleskill, New York, for the position of trustee as to the defendant/respondent Robert LaPietra; (2) declaring that Mr. LaPietra is not a resident of the Village of Cobleskill for purposes of Public Officers Law §3(1) and § 30;1 (3) declaring that Mr. LaPietra is not qualified to serve as trustee in the Village of Cobleskill; and (4) declaring that a vacancy exists in that position.
Petitioners assert that on November 4, 2008, Mr. LaPietra was a candidate for office on the ballot for one of two open seats for the position of village trustee in the Village of Cobleskill. As a result of the general election, Mr. LaPietra was elected into one of the open seats for village trustee. Yet, petitioners argue, Mr. LaPietra was not a resident of the Village of Cobleskill before, on or after November 4, 2008, and is, therefore, not eligible to serve as a village trustee.
The respondents oppose the relief sought by petitioners. Furthermore, in his answer, Mr. LaPietra claims that he has “at all times relevant” been a resident of the Village of Cobleskill. On December 8, 2008 and December 16, 2008, a hearing was held with respect to the petitioners’ application for preliminary relief. As a preliminary matter, both the county respondents *370and Mr. LaPietra argue that this court has no subject matter jurisdiction in a summary proceeding to remove a successful candidate from public office.2 The court will first address the issue of subject matter jurisdiction.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit