Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit July 2, 2009, Nos. 07-16471, 07-16473 (Flagship West, LLC v. Excel Realty Partners LP)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-07-2009
MEMORANDUM *
Excel Realty Partners LP (“Excel”) appeals the district court’s order granting Excel’s tenant, Flagship West, LLC (“Flagship”), rescission of its lease based on a determination that Excel materially violated an “exclusive use” provision of that lease. The district court invoked judicial estoppel to prevent Excel from asserting that § 4.5 of the lease bars rescission. Because we find judicial estoppel was not warranted here, we remand for the district court to determine whether rescission is an available remedy under California law and the terms of the contract.
Determining whether judicial estoppel should be invoked is informed by several factors: (1) whether a party adopts a position clearly inconsistent with its earlier position; (2) whether the court accepted the party’s earlier position; and (3) whether the party would gain an unfair advantage or impose an unfair detriment on the opposing party if not estopped. New Hampshire v. Maine, 532 U.S. 742, 750-51, 121 S.Ct. 1808, 149 L.Ed.2d 968 (2001). These factors do not weigh in favor of judicial estoppel in the present case.
First, Excel’s litigation positions were not clearly inconsistent. There is no evidence that Excel ever conceded that rescission was available to Flagship. Although the Pretrial Order did not specifically cite § 4.5 of the lease or discuss all of the arguments that might be based on the section, it acknowledged that Excel contested Plaintiffs’ entitlement to rescind, at least on both materiality and independent covenant grounds. Other related arguments that rescission was not available, including *681the contractual limitation on remedies argument at issue, were adequately embraced within the order. See Miller v. Safeco Title Ins. Co., 758 F.2d 364, 368 (9th Cir.1985) (Pretrial orders “should be liberally construed to permit any issues at trial that are embraced within [their] language.”) (internal quotation omitted).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit