Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit December 18, 2009, No. 09-1267 (United States v. Gradys)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-2009

OPINION OF THE COURT

NYGAARD, Circuit Judge.

Because our opinion is wholly without precedential value, and because the parties and the District Court are familiar with its operative facts, we offer only an abbreviated recitation to explain why we will affirm the judgment of conviction and sentence of the District Court.

Appellant, Alexandre Gradys, raises two issues on appeal. He asserts that, in violation of Rule 703 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, the District Court erred by failing to conduct a balancing test before admitting the testimony of a fingerprint *482expert, since he relied, in part, on a fingerprint card that the District Court ruled inadmissible.1 Gradys also argues that, even if the District Court is found to have conducted a balancing test it violated Rule 703 by failing to give a special jury instruction on the expert testimony.2 The testimony at issue focused upon whether Gradys’ inked fingerprint impressions taken after his arrest on September 24, 2008 by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agent matched a fingerprint record contained in a 2002 Form 1-296, Warrant of Deportation/Removal, that the agent discovered in Gradys’ alien file after the arrest.

Gradys objected during trial to the expert’s testimony, the newer fingerprint record, and the expert’s report. The objections were raised under Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, because the government disclosed the expert, report, and supporting documents two weeks after the discovery deadline. At sidebar, Gradys argued that he was prejudiced because the three weeks between the disclosures and the start of trial was an insufficient amount of time to mount a defense against this evidence. Gradys admitted, however, that he did not file a pretrial motion on these issues in that three-week period because he thought it was probable that the District Court would merely grant a continuance.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.