Indiana Supreme Court December 18, 2009, 84A01-0801-CV-30 (Mercho Roushdi Shoemaker Dilley Thoraco Vascular Corp. v. James W. Blatchford, III, M.D., and Eve G. Cieutat, M.D.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-2009

ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLANT ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEES

Robert A. Garelick John J. Morse

Steven M. Crell Indianapolis, Indiana

Heather Wysong Zaiger

FILED

Indianapolis, Indiana

Dec 18 2009, 3:01 pm

In the

CLERK

Indiana Supreme Court of the supreme court,

court of appeals and

tax court

No. 84A01-0801-CV-30

MERCHO-ROUSHDI-SHOEMAKER-DILLEY

THORACO-VASCULAR CORPORATION,

Appellant (Defendant below),

v.

JAMES W. BLATCHFORD, III, M.D., and

EVE G. CIEUTAT, M.D.,

Appellees (Plaintiffs below).

Appeal from the Vigo Superior Court, Division I, No. 84D01-9912-CP-1990

The Honorable Michael H. Eldred, Judge

On Petition to Transfer from the Indiana Court of Appeals, No. 84A01-0801-CV-30

December 18, 2009

Shepard, Chief Justice, dissenting from the denial of transfer.

An Indiana group of open-heart surgeons with facilities in Indianapolis and Terre Haute

recruited a husband-wife team from Texas to provide more staff capacity at its Terre Haute

operation. The parties negotiated rather elaborate, if ordinary, agreements that covered various

aspects of their business relationship, from stock purchase arrangements to dissolution

procedures to noncompetition provisions.

When the Texas doctors decided several years later to set up a competing practice of their

own in Terre Haute, they and their former associates sued each other in claim and counterclaim.

In the first round of this litigation, the Court of Appeals affirmed denial of injunctive relief on

grounds that an adequate remedy existed at law.

In this round, the Court of Appeals has held that enforcing the business agreements of

physicians is contrary to public policy as harmful to patients. The facts here illuminate only the

opposite.

History of the Relationship

Doctors Mercho, Roushdi, Shoemaker, and Dilley practiced open-heart surgery together

through the corporation bearing their names (MRSD), which has operated in Indianapolis since

1972. In 1985, Terre Haute Regional Hospital approached Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.