South Dakota Supreme Court December 22, 2009, 25205, 25212 (Schwartz v. Morgan)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-2009

#25205, #25212-a-JKK

2009 SD 110

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA

* * * *

GREGG W. AND SHARON K.

SCHWARTZ, Plaintiffs and Appellants,

v.

SALLY R. MORGAN, Defendant and Appellee.

* * * *

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT

OF THE FIRST JUDICIAL CIRCUIT

UNION COUNTY, SOUTH DAKOTA

* * * *

HONORABLE STEVEN R. JENSEN

Judge

* * * *

SABRINA L. SAYLER of

Crary, Huff, Inkster, Sheehan,

Ringgenberg, Hartnett & Storm, PC Attorneys for plaintiffs

Dakota Dunes, South Dakota and appellants.

ROBERT B. DECK of

Deck Law Attorneys for defendant

Sioux City, Iowa and appellee.

* * * *

ARGUED ON NOVEMBER 19, 2009

OPINION FILED 12/22/09

#25205, #25212

KONENKAMP, Justice

[¶1.] A purchaser of residential real estate brought suit against a seller for

fraudulent concealment of the fact that the driveway encroached on a neighbor’s

property. The jury returned a verdict in favor of the purchaser. Holding that there

was insufficient evidence that the seller was aware of the encroachment, the circuit

court granted a judgment notwithstanding the verdict. Because we find that the

seller owed no duty to the purchaser by the time the suit was commenced, we

affirm.

Background

[¶2.] In 1997, Gregg and Sharon Schwartz purchased a residence at 53

Sunset Drive from Sally Morgan. The home sits on one of several lots in Riv-R-

Land Estates in Union County, South Dakota. The Schwartzes did not personally

have the property surveyed, but instead relied on the survey obtained by their

mortgage company. In 2002, the Schwartzes decided to sell the house. A potential

purchaser had the property surveyed in contemplation of the sale. The survey

revealed that three quarters of the driveway encroached on the neighbor’s lot. The

Schwartzes attempted to rectify the problem, but the sale could not be saved in

time. They were eventually able to resolve the boundary and encroachment issues

and sell the house to another buyer, but not without much time and expense.

[¶3.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.