Alaska Supreme Court July 10, 2009, S-12586 (Progressive Casualty Insurance Co. v. Skin)

WINFREE, Justice,

with whom MATTHEWS, Justice, joins, dissenting in part. ' '

I respectfully disagree with the court's conclusion that Joseph Skin is entitled to medical-payments -(med-pay) coverage under his mother's policy. In my view this conclusion is inconsistent and incompatible with our *1104decision that Joseph Skin is not entitled to liability coverage under the policy.