Supreme Court of New Jersey June 21, 2010, A-62 September Term 2009 (Estate of Hanges v. Metropolitan Property & Casualty Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-06-2010

Justice RIVERA-SOTO

delivered the opinion of the Court.

N.J.R.E.

804(b)(6) codifies an exception to the hearsay rule. It allows, in civil proceedings only, the admission of “a statement made by a person unavailable as a witness because of death if the statement was made in good faith upon declarant’s personal knowledge in circumstances indicating that it is trustworthy.”

Ibid.

In the context of a summary judgment motion, the trial court disallowed the admission of several hearsay statements made by a decedent concerning the cause of an automobile accident, ruling that, because it was in the decedent’s self-interest to color the version of the events he gave to the police in the light most favorable to him, that self-interest automatically rendered that hearsay statement not in good faith and untrustworthy, thus inadmissible. The Appellate Division, although sustaining several of the evidentiary determinations made by the trial court concern

*374

ing the decedent’s later hearsay statements, disagreed with the trial court’s rejection of the statements made by the decedent to a police officer shortly after the accident. It concluded that there was no factual basis in the record to support the trial court’s determination that such statement was not made in good faith or was not trustworthy.

We agree. As a threshold matter, we observe that, ordinarily, an evidentiary determination made during trial is entitled to deference and is to be reversed only on a finding of an abuse of discretion; we see no reason to impose a different standard of review on an evidentiary determination made, as here, in the context of a summary judgment application. Applying that standard of review, the record discloses that the sole reason proffered by the trial court in determining that the hearsay statement was not trustworthy—that it was in the declarant’s self-interest to make the statement—lacked an evidential foundation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.