Louisiana Court of Appeal January 27, 2010, 45,039-KA (State v. Stutts)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-01-2010

STATE OF LOUISIANA, Appellee v. TODD GRIFFIN STUTTS, Appellant. No. 45,039-KA. Court of Appeals of Louisiana, Second Circuit. January 27, 2010. Not Designated for Publication. G. PAUL MARX, Louisiana Appellate Project, Counsel for Appellant. JERRY L. JONES, District Attorney, R. NICOLAS ANDERSON, Assistant District Attorney, Counsel for Appellee. Before BROWN, STEWART and CARAWAY, JJ. CARAWAY, J. Todd Stutts pled guilty as charged to second degree battery, a violation of La. R.S. 14:43.1, and received the maximum sentence of five years' imprisonment at hard labor. Stutts appeals his sentence as excessive. We affirm. The record shows that on December 27, 2007, Stutts became involved in a physical altercation with his ex-girlfriend during which he bit off a large "chunk" of the victim's ear causing permanent disfigurement. The victim also received a cut above her eye and three broken ribs. As a result of a plea bargain agreement, Stutts pled guilty as charged to second degree battery and the state dismissed a simple criminal damage to property charge arising from the incident. The victim made statements to the court at both the guilty plea and sentencing proceedings. Before sentencing Stutts, the trial court noted its consideration of the pre-sentence investigation report. The court also discussed the facts of the case at length and noted the grievous nature of the victim's injury and the continuous struggle between Stutts and the victim during this crime of violence. Stutts' prior criminal record, which included one felony conviction,[1] and his history of alcohol abuse, which caused the loss of his job, were noted. The court acknowledged its belief that there was a strong possibility that violence would recur. Stutts was sentenced to five years of imprisonment at hard labor — the maximum term of imprisonment. No optional fine was imposed. The defendant's timely filed motion to reconsider sentence was denied without a hearing. This appeal followed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.