District Court of Appeal of Florida March 10, 2010, 3D09-656, 3D09-837 (MacIas v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-2010

PER CURIAM.

ON MOTIONS FOR REHEARING AND CONSOLIDATION

Upon consideration of the appellant’s

*1183

motions for rehearing

1

and for consolidation of the same appellant’s Case No. 8D09-837 with

Macias v. State,

Case No. 3D09-656, we withdraw the per curiam affirmance filed June 10, 2009 in the higher-numbered case and substitute the opinion which follows. For the reasons detailed below, we also grant the motion for consolidation and remand both cases to the circuit court for further proceedings.

The issue involved in both cases

2

is whether the trial court erred in denying motions to vacate pleas of no contest under

State v. Green,

944 So.2d 208 (Fla.2006). The motions in each of the circuit court cases alleged that the defendant was not given an immigration warning as required by applicable law, and that he is now subject to removal from the United States by immigration authorities as a result of his pleas in those cases. Each motion was filed within the two-year window prescribed in

Green.

In an inadvertent judicial variation of “Catch 22,” each motion was denied by the trial court because of the decisional law precluding relief if the challenged plea is not the only basis for removal of the defendant under the immigration laws. Although motions to vacate plea were filed and pending in both cases, the first court determined that the existence of the plea in the second case would subject the defendant to removal even if relief were to be granted in the first case, and vice versa. Under

Green,

however, the defendant may prevail if he demonstrates an entitlement to relief from plea in

both

cases.

In fairness to the trial courts and this Court, the defendant’s motions are responsible for the confusion. Neither identified the other case or included (under oath) an allegation that the defendant was

also

entitled to vacate his plea in the other felony case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.