District Court of Appeal of Florida February 10, 2010, 4D08-962 (JPG ENTERPRISES, INC. v. McLellan)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-02-2010

TAYLOR, J.

In this appeal and cross-appeal involving the construction of a home upon land owned by the buyer, the trial court certified a question to our court as one of great public importance. We restate the certified question as follows:

WHETHER THE ESCROW DEPOSIT REQUIREMENT OF SECTION 501.1375, FLORIDA STATUTES, APPLIES TO GENERAL CONTRACTORS WHO CONTRACT TO BUILD A SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE UPON LAND OWNED BY THE CONSUMER AT THE TIME THE CONTRACT IS SIGNED.

For the reasons discussed below, we answer the certified question in the negative.

Factual Background

Sean and Jacqueline McLellan entered into a written contract with JPG Enterprises, Inc. (“JPG”) for the construction of a single-family house on real property already owned by the McLellans. They deposited $15,384.70 towards the purchase price. Ultimately, the McLellans can-celled the contract due to a delay that was neither party’s fault. JPG asserted that it was entitled to keep the deposit based on the wording of the contract.

The McLellans sued JPG in county court seeking a return of their deposit. Their third amended complaint contained three counts: (I) Breach of Contract, (II) Violation of the Florida Deceptive and Un

*823

fair Trade Practices Act, and (III) Violation of Florida Statute § 501.1375. In Count III, the McLellans alleged that JPG was a “building contractor” and “developer” who, pursuant to the statute, had to deposit monies in an escrow account on their behalf so that the money could be returned if the McLellans properly terminated the contract.

After a trial in county court, a jury found that JPG breached the contract by not returning the remainder of the deposit (Count I). As to Count II, the trial court directed a verdict, rejecting the Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices claim as a matter of law. The court tried Count III non-jury and found that JPG violated section 501.1375, Florida Statutes (2008).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.