Supreme Court of Missouri January 26, 2010, SC 90041 (Burns v. Smith)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-01-2010
LAURA DENVIR STITH, Judge.
Eric Burns recovered a $2,044,278 judgment against Lynn Smith for damages he received when a weld that Mr. Smith had placed on a cement mixer failed, causing the truck to explode and seriously injure its driver, Mr. Burns. Mr. Burns then filed this equitable garnishment action against Mr. Smith’s insurance policies with Farmers Alliance Mutual Insurance and Oak River Insurance Company, neither of which had provided a defense. Farmers appeals the judgment holding that its policy’s “business pursuits” exclusion is inapplicable and that under its contract it is liable for prejudgment interest on the portion of the judgment equal to its policy limits and for post-judgment interest on the entire judgment.
This Court affirms the judgment in part, reverses it in part and remands. Farmers’ business pursuits exclusion does not apply because the injury did not occur in the course of the insured’s “business,” which is defined narrowly in the portion of the policy relevant here to be “[a] trade, profession or occupation, excluding farming,
and
the use of any premises or portion of residence premises for any such purposes.” This Court rejects Farmers’ invitation to come to a different result either by holding that the word “and” as used in the exclusion unambiguously means “or” or by modifying long-settled black-letter law requiring ambiguities in a policy to be resolved in favor of the insured and, instead, by engaging in a fact-based analysis of each party’s subjective intent and interpretation of the contract.
The Court also affirms that Farmers must pay prejudgment interest on the portion of the judgment that does not exceed its $1 million policy limit and pay post-judgment interest accruing on the entire judgment. Once Oak River paid $675,000 of the judgment, interest could accrue only on the remaining unpaid portion of the judgment.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit