Supreme Court of Missouri May 11, 2010, SC 90425 (Smith v. Pace)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-05-2010
MICHAEL A. WOLFF, Judge.
Introduction
The prosecution of a lawyer for criminal contempt of court for words the lawyer wrote in a writ pleading is a difficult and untidy business, as this case shows: The lawyer’s duty of zealous advocacy and freedom of speech may clash with the courts’ inherent power to protect its proceedings.
At the outset, it should be noted that this habeas corpus proceeding reviews a judgment based on the court’s inherent power to punish for criminal contempt, where a jury found the accused attorney, Carl Smith, guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of indirect criminal contempt of court. The result of this proceeding has no bearing on any disciplinary measures that may result from the attorney’s conduct.
Smith was prosecuted for criminal contempt of court for strong words he used in petitioning the court of appeals for a writ seeking to quash a subpoena issued for a grand jury in Douglas County. Referring to the prosecuting attorney and the judge overseeing the grand jury, Smith wrote: “Their participating in the convening, overseeing, and handling the [sic] proceedings of this grand jury are, in the least, an appearance of impropriety and, at most, a
*127
conspiracy by these officers of the court to threaten, instill fear and imprison innocent persons to cover-up and chill public awareness of their own apparent misconduct using the power of their positions to do so.”
Strong words, indeed. Smith says his words are protected by the First Amendment. The state, on behalf of the respondent judge and sheriff, says they are not.
The jury was instructed to determine— in the curious language of earlier Missouri cases — whether Smith’s “statements degraded and made impotent the authority of [the court] and impeded and embarrassed the administration of justice.”
See State ex rel. Chassaing v. Mummert,
887 S.W.2d 573, 578 (Mo. banc 1994). The jury found Smith guilty of criminal contempt.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit