Indiana Court of Appeals April 23, 2010, 18A04-0906-CV-347 (FARMERS ELEV. CO. OF OAKVILLE v. Hamilton)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-04-2010
926 N.E.2d 68 (2010) FARMERS ELEVATOR COMPANY OF OAKVILLE, INC., Estate of Tim Norris, Dan Bronnenberg, Rick Harter, Justin Day, Charles Whitehair, and J.B. Chapman, Appellants-Respondents, v. John A. HAMILTON, Appellee-Petitioner. No. 18A04-0906-CV-347. Court of Appeals of Indiana. April 23, 2010. *71 Thomas M. Beeman, Anderson, IN, John H. Brooke, Douglas Mawhorr, *72 Brooke Mawhorr, Muncie, IN, Attorneys for Appellants. Kurt A. Webber, Kurt A. Webber, P.C., Carmel, IN, Attorney for Appellee. MEMORANDUM DECISION VAIDIK, Judge. Case Summary The plaintiff farmer and defendant cooperative executed four hedge-to-arrive contracts for the sale of grain. Each contract stated a price, type, and quantity of grain to be delivered. None of the contracts specified a delivery date. The contracts also omitted rolling fees, but the farmer extended his delivery periods several times and was charged for each extension. The farmer ultimately did not deliver, and the contracts were cancelled. The farmer executed a series of promissory notes agreeing to compensate the co-op. He tendered a series of payments thereafter. The farmer then brought this action alleging, among other things, that the grain purchase agreements were unlawful and void "futures contracts." A jury found in his favor, and the co-op now appeals. We hold as a matter of law that the grain purchase agreements were valid and enforceable "forward contracts." We also hold that the applicable statutes of limitations barred the farmer's claim for breach of fiduciary duty and partially barred his claim for money had and received. We further clarify that the co-op did not waive its motions for judgment on the evidence by calling additional witnesses after the motions were denied by the trial court. We reverse and remand. Facts and Procedural History Farmers Elevator Company of Oakville, Inc. ("FECO") was an agricultural cooperative that purchased grain from local farmers.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit