Supreme Court of Vermont April 5, 2010, 09-173 (In Re Paynter 2-Lot Subdivision)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-04-2010

¶ 1. Applicant Bruce Paynter appeals from a decision by the Environmental Court to remand his application to the Town of Pittsford Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA) for reconsideration under the Town’s 1989 zoning ordinance. Applicant contends that the Town’s 2005 zoning ordinance, not the 1989 ordinance, applies to his application and that the court incorrectly concluded that the 2005 ordinance was void and unenforceable. We affirm.

V 2. Applicant owns a 0.56-aere lot in Pittsford, Vermont, and in March 2008, submitted a complete zoning permit application to subdivide the property into two proposed lots.

1

The Pittsford Zoning Administrator, applying the 2005 ordinance, rejected the application on April 15, 2008. Applicant appealed this decision to the ZBA, and it affirmed the denial based on applicant’s failure to comply with the frontage requirements embodied in the 2005 ordinance. Applicant then appealed the ZBA decision to the Environmental Court.

¶ 3. While the case was pending before the Environmental Court and after the parties had filed cross-motions for summary judgment on the merits, the Town discovered that the 2005 ordinance had been adopted after the expiration of the 2000 town plan and before a subsequent town plan had been adopted. Under 24 V.S.A. § 4387(c), “[u]pon the expiration of a [town] plan, all [zoning] bylaws ... then in effect shall remain in effect, but shall not be amended until a plan is in effect.” The Town determined that the 1989 ordinance was the zoning ordinance in effect when the 2000 town plan expired and concluded, according to the terms of the statute, that it could not be replaced with a subsequent zoning ordinance until a

*638

new town plan was ratified. Consistent with its conclusion, the Town filed a motion to remand the application to the ZBA for reconsideration under the 1989 ordinance.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.