United States Bankruptcy Court, D. New Jersey July 8, 2010, 19-11681 (PermaLife Products, LLC v. TSJ Dirt, LLC (In Re PermaLife Products, LLC))

Also known as

United States · · · 08-07-2010

*506

OPINION

MORRIS STERN, Bankruptcy Judge.

I.

INTRODUCTION.

Chapter 11 debtor-plaintiff PermaLife Products, LLC (“PermaLife”) and its co-debtors

1

complain in this adversary proceeding of postpetition stay violations, i.e., acts first to obtain possession of certain equipment said to be property of the estate, and then participation in an auction sale and prompt resale of the equipment. Resale proceeds are said to dwarf the winning $5,000 auction bid.

The defendants include TSJ Dirt, LLC (“TSJ”), owner of a certain facility in Eloy, Arizona which housed the equipment in question. TSJ, exercising a self-help remedy under Arizona landlord lien law, sold the equipment to satisfy a rent-default claim against a nondebtor lessee. This nondebtor was subject to common ownership with the debtor, and PermaLife is said to have guaranteed the lease. Other defendants include auction sale and resale facilitators and those in the chain of equipment acquirers.

Included in the array of proceeding issues is the state of knowledge of TSJ and other defendants of the debtors’ bankruptcy and any debtor’s ownership of the equipment at the time of the targeted acts. However, the immediate question is one of venue. A number of defendants have moved to

dismiss, citing

28 U.S.C. § 1409(d).

2

They submit that the debtors’ proceeding does not qualify for venue in this district (where the Chapter 11 cases are ongoing) because their claim arises postpetition “from the operation of the business of the debtor” in the District of Arizona. That district is said to be the proper proceeding situs. The plaintiffs counter, contending that their claim is a matter of bankruptcy administration and that they are to benefit from the Chapter 11 case court venue permitted by 28 U.S.C. § 1409(a).

3

II.

THE ARIZONA RUBBER FIRE AND THE ELOY, ARIZONA LEASE.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.