United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Minnesota December 20, 2010, 09-30651 (Kelley v. Hofer (In Re Petters Co.))

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-2010

ORDER DENYING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR TRANSFER TO DISTRICT COURT

GREGORY F. KISHEL, Bankruptcy Judge.

This adversary proceeding is one among 200-plus commenced by the Plaintiff, in his capacity as trustee in the bankruptcy cases of Debtors Petters Company, Inc. (“PCI”), Petters Group Worldwide, LLC, and their related entities. It is part of a so-called “clawback” effort, undertaken to redress what is alleged to have been a large-scale Ponzi scheme that left 3.5 billion dollars or more in unsatisfied creditors’ claims after its collapse. (In early October, 2008, the key person in the underlying businesses — Thomas J. Petters— was arrested and charged federally, and his business entities ceased operations.)

The term “clawback” is an unfortunate feature of current legal-journalistic jargon, coarse and not too illuminative of the trustee’s underlying mission. Via “clawback,” a trustee or receiver puts all parties that transacted with the purveyor of a failed Ponzi scheme onto a parity in the matter of restitution. This would be done by invoking remedies of avoidance (under theories of fraudulent transfer, unjust enrichment, and the like) against those lenders and investors who got repaid in whole or in part before the collapse. The extant wreckage of the scheme, i.e., the property that had remained in-hand with the purveyor as of the collapse, would be augmented by recoveries of funds from those lenders and investors who got out early. The identity of parties subject to the trustee’s claims would be fixed by a temporal measurement, as those that had been paid during the periods of vulnerability to avoidance or recovery specified by the law of fraudulent transfer or other invoked remedies. Those with debts unsatisfied at the downfall would share pro rata with those whose claims would perforce be revived via the avoidance of the payments to them and the recovery from them of corresponding amounts of money.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.