California Court of Appeal October 15, 2010, C059777 (People v. Assad)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-2010

Opinion

ROBIE, J.

In this case, we conclude defendant’s trial counsel was not ineffective in failing to request a jury instruction that would have directed the jury to consider whether evidence of defendant’s cultural background raised a reasonable doubt as to whether defendant had the requisite intent to inflict torture and aggravated mayhem on his son when defendant physically disciplined him. Defendant was not entitled to the jury instruction he now proposes because his proposed instruction would have constituted an improper comment on the evidence.

A jury found defendant Loui Mahmoud Assad guilty of torturing his son, Y. (count 1), committing aggravated mayhem on Y. (count 2), five counts of inflicting corporal injury on Y. (counts 3-7), and one count of inflicting corporal injury on his daughter N. (count 9). The jury found that when inflicting corporal injury on Y. (counts 3-7) defendant personally inflicted great bodily injury. It acquitted him of one count of inflicting corporal injury on Y. (count 8) and one count of inflicting corporal injury on his other daughter, R. (count 10).

1

The trial court sentenced defendant to prison for a determinate term of nine years, consisting of the six-year upper term on count 5 plus three years for the enhancement, followed by concurrent indeterminate terms of life with the possibility of parole on counts 1 and 2. The court imposed concurrent terms

*191

of nine years on counts 6, 7, and 9. The court stayed sentence on counts 3 and 4 pursuant to Penal Code

2

section 654.

On appeal, defendant contends (1) his trial counsel was ineffective in failing to request a pinpoint jury instruction on his “cultural defense”; (2) there was insufficient evidence to support his convictions for aggravated mayhem and torture; and (3) his sentences on counts

1 or 2 and

5 through 7 must be stayed pursuant to section 654. Finding no merit in these arguments, we will affirm the judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.