Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma May 7, 2010, 107,316. Released for Publication by Order of the Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma, Division No. 3 (INC. CITY OF GROVE, DELAWARE CTY. v. Boyce)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-05-2010
ROBERT DICK BELL, Viee-Chief Judge.
T1 Defendants/Appellants, Vernon Boyce and Boyee Investments, LLC., §/h/a All American Outdoor Advertising Company (Boyce), appeal from the trial court's judgment permanently enjoining Boyce from constructing billboards on certain property deemed to be within the city limits of Plaintiff/ Appellee, City of Grove (City). For the reasons set forth below, we affirm.
12 In 2007, Boyce leased certain real property (Subject Property) from the landowner for the purpose of erecting billboards. After Boyee began constructing billboards in July 2008, City filed a petition for injunctive relief. City's petition alleged the billboards were in violation of City of Grove Municipal Ordinance No. 451, which prohibits, with certain exceptions, all non-accessory and billboard signs within the city limits of Grove. Boyce counterclaimed, asserting the Subject Property had been de-annexed by City via Municipal Ordinance No. 404 on December 3, 1996. Defendant/Appellee, The Grand River Dam Authority (GRDA), was later added as a party at the direction of the trial court.
T3 Both City and Boyce filed motions for summary judgment. The trial court denied Boyee's motion and granted City's motion. Specifically, the trial court permanently enjoined Boyee from constructing billboards on the Subject Property and ordered Boyce to remove all construction thus far completed. From said judgment, Boyce appeals. This matter stands submitted for accelerated appellate review on the trial court record pursuant to Rule 18(h), Rules for District Courts, 12 0.8. Supp.2002, Ch. 2, App., and Rule 1.36, Oklahoma Supreme Court Rules, 12 O.S. Supp.2003, Ch. 15, App. 1.
14 This Court's standard of review of a trial court's grant of summary judgment is de novo. Hoyt v. Paul R. Miller, M.D., Inc., 1996 OK 80, ¶ 2, 921 P.2d 350, 351-52.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit