Superior Court of Pennsylvania March 5, 2010, 337 WDA 2009, No. 417 WDA 2009 (Safe Auto Insurance Co. v. Berlin)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-03-2010
OPINION BY
BENDER, J.:
¶ 1 Melody Berlin and McKean Hose Company (collectively, the Appellants) appeal the trial court’s entry of a declaratory judgment in favor of Safe Auto Insurance Company (Safe Auto) determining that Safe Auto has no obligation to reimburse the McKean Hose Company for the cost of an emergency rescue it conducted on Berlin’s behalf. The Appellants contend that the language of Safe Auto’s policy is ambiguous and that when interpreted in favor of the insured, the policy mandates the
*329
extension of Berlin’s coverage to the expenses the Hose Company incurred. Upon review of the policy’s language, we find no merit in the Appellants’ claims. Accordingly, we affirm the trial court’s entry of declaratory judgment.
1
¶ 2 McKean Hose Company is a volunteer firefighting company that provides emergency services to McKean Township, Erie County. The Hose Company’s claim arises out of a single vehicle auto accident in which Berlin’s car skidded off the road, requiring emergency rescue. During the course of the rescue, the Hose Company used emergency equipment and supplies including eight flares, two hand lights, four hand tools, one generator, one set of cribbing and a hose truck. The supplies expended were valued at $1,194. One week after the rescue, on April 10, 2007, the Hose Company attempted, through Pennsylvania Fire Recovery Services, to obtain reimbursement for that amount from Safe Auto, billing the company for coverage under Berlin’s policy. When Safe Auto did not respond, the recovery service followed up with a second invoice dated June 28, 2007. The parties engaged in no further communication until February 11, 2008, after Safe Auto had commenced the underlying action and served process on the Hose Company.
¶ 3 Safe Auto’s complaint named both Berlin and McKean Hose Company as defendants and both filed answers and new matter.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit