Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas November 17, 2010, PD-1059-09 (Grant v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-2010

WOMACK, J.,

delivered the opinion of the unanimous Court.

The appellant, Derrick Dwayne Grant, pled guilty to burglary of a habitation with a deadly weapon. After a jury trial on punishment, he was sentenced to 55 years in prison. The Tenth Court of Appeals reversed the judgment, holding that the trial court erred in denying the appellant’s Batson

1

challenge to the State’s exercise of peremptory strikes. The Court found that the State’s explanation for striking venire member J. Franklin was a pretext for racial discrimination because “there was no meaningful examination of Franklin regarding the reason the State used to strike him.”

We granted the State’s petition for discretionary review to determine whether a lack of meaningful questioning can be sufficient, on its own, to support a

Batson

challenge, and whether the Court of Appeals properly applied the “clearly erroneous” standard of review. We hold that a lack of meaningful questioning might be sufficient to support a

Batson

challenge under the appropriate circumstances, but the Court of Appeals erred in applying the standard of review in this case. We therefore reverse the Court’s decision and remand for consideration of the remaining claims.

*657

I. Standard of Review

In

Batson,

the United States Supreme Court held that, while a prosecutor ordinarily may exercise peremptory strikes for any reason related to his views concerning the outcome of the trial, “the Equal Protection Clause forbids the prosecutor to challenge potential jurors solely on account of their race.”

2

A

Batson

challenge to a peremptory strike consists of three steps. First, the opponent of the strike must establish a

prima facie

showing of racial discrimination. Second, the proponent of the strike must articulate a race-neutral explanation. Third, the trial court must decide whether the opponent has proved purposeful racial discrimination.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.